Brooklyn Square Pizza

While score is great, I expected better. Maybe it was all the hype. Or maybe because it wasn’t a fresh pie and was a reheat (not sure how long out there, I’m here slightly past lunch rush). I like it a lot but don’t see myself driving out of the way to get it. If I’m in the area will definitely stop again and next time get a fresh pie to see if different.

pretty damn good za

Brave

Tried both the square and round slices. Ended up getting a round pie and loving it. Great flavor, thin and crispy. Why can’t all pizza be this good?

One bite festival really really good for a square

Great Sicilian style upside down pizza. Light dough but also cooked with crispy crust.

What an amazing spot! The pizza (and all the food) was AMAZING!! Staff is wonderful! The owner stopped by to Check on us- great guy!! We drove here from Syracuse and it was worth the drive!!!!

Amazing pizza, definitely worth an 8.9

PHENOMENAL UPSIDE DOWN SQUARE

The upside down lives up to all the hype. Great crispy crust and one of the better tasting sauces of any pizza place I’ve been to.

This score would have been higher for this Upside Down Square if it wasn’t so salty. The sauce, mozzarella and crust are very good but whoever made this put too much Pecorino romano which is a salty hard grated cheese. Their vodka slice was salty too and their regular round slice is about pretty good but why the sesame seeds? Another disappointing review after driving 2 hours.

Extremely safe to say that this is the best square slice I’ve had in my pizza eating career. Everything is perfect from the pillowy cheese sandwiched between a slightly sweet and chunky sauce and the fluffy crust. I’m a 2.5 hour drive from Brooklyn square and have no shame or hesitation at all in making that drive to get a slice of this goodness. It’s a great slice but be prepared as these things are heavy but you can’t stop at 1, it’s just that good. Just wish the undercarriage had a tiny bit more color and wish the sauce had a pinch more of salt and some oregano, otherwise these guys are not playing around and the og upside down is a heavy hitter. I recommend this spot to anyone who loves pizza. Orlando was great and welcoming and made sure we enjoyed our meal. Definitely coming back

Classic jersey pizza atmosphere. Pizza was great - as good as Sicilian can be or at least close. Sauce is delicious and best part. One of those that feels both light and heavy. Textbook flavor profile, which is both a strength and what holds it back from higher score.

spectacular pizza. slight crunch with every bite. it’s thick and airy, yet you can still taste the sauce and a little cheese. the dough and sauce is what really makes this pizza imo. great pizza. did not disappoint. well worth the 30 min travel

My favorite slice in NJ. Sauce to cheese ratio is perfection. Tangy sauce pairs well with fresh mozz. Fluffy with crispy undercarriage. Crave this every time I’m back home

Really good pizza but not nearly the best ever. It was pretty crispy and the cheese is great.

Good flavor and crisp

Excellent pizza. Crust is crispy, cheese is perfect, and the sauce is slightly tangy.

Round slice 7.5, I like the sesame seed crust. Upside down square 8.4, light fluffy crust with good crunch to the bottom. Sauce is a little sweet but a delicious home depth.

This is more than likely one of if not the best Sicilian you can get your hands on. A full pie can probably feed 4 and have some leftover. Sauce is sweet, you can taste the quality of the cheese. Crust is awesome.