Brother Bruno's Pizzeria Middletown

Finally our first pizza review in Orange County! I never had it before but Michael probably has, really good pizza there! Even though it’s a little greasy which it ends with some flop. The weird part that it’s also crispy at the same time as for the crust, still enjoyed it. The grandma slice was also tasty. Grandma slice: 8.4 Michael’s rating: 8.3 Grandma slice: 8.3

Really good undercarriage, good flavor, thin and crispy.

Excellent slice, classic football pie. They had a nice selection of specialty pizza I highly recommend a visit to this place I will be back when I’m in the area.

Solid sauce and really good cheese. Was really floppy, overly greasy, and the dough reminded me of something that I used to get at an arcade when I was a kid. So far best I've had in Orange county but that isn't saying much. Saw the high scores expected more Middletown.

Crispy and thin, had a heated up slices vs a fresh pie, which I think might have made it a little less flavorful. But all in all solid slice.

Crust is doughy not crisp at all very chewy!

Perfection

A lite pizza soft and doughy can see it made in front of you

Great slice. Tangy sauce, perfect crust thickness, just right amount of cheese. Classic NY slice.

Excellent slice, thin and flavorful

Yooo they got the best pizza don't @ me

Perfect 10 🍕🍕👌🏼

Nice crisp slice. Perfect ratio of cheese & sauce. Love the crunch

At time of order this place was rated 8.5. No way, not even close. Crust was rubbery, decent sauce. huge lack of cheese, some slices had none.

Best NY street slice. Sauce to cheese ratio is on point & perfect crust crunch.

Not bad. Good football pizza.

One hell of a slice.. great sauce and cheese. The perfect crust . Best slice yet 8.6!!