Brothers Pizza - New York Style

Good taste, little flop, wonderful crunch.

Great cheese. Sauce is fine. Crust is a little chewy but good flavor. Cheese/grease combo wins it

This is a rather deceiving flop for this slice, as the crust had a good base and the top wasn’t too heavy. Crust has some fluff, but a slight crisp to the base of the dough. Stringy cheese, which is always a turn off, but the sauce had the slightest tang to it to save it, but the red pepper and oregano on top gave it a very good taste. If it wasn’t for the cheese, this would be great. One of the better slices in State College

Great crisp overall . This is a reheated slice but it’s hard to tell. Sweeter sauce.Cheese just exists , no real flavor to it .

not a bad slice decent cheese but the sauce isn't good, not bad for a college slice

Very bland but nice family

Thin, but no flop. Good, crispy crust. Sauce seems almost nonexistent. Overall, not bad. Decent on State College standards.

Sauce to sweet. Not a fan of the oregano. Cheese was meh. Crust was decent tho so that saves it.

Top 5 worst buffalo slices. All time.

Alright Frankie this is a light crunchy slice. Sauce has a lot of oregano and garlic. Cheese little greasy but overall it’s a good football pizza

Not bad, cheese is pretty good.

Best in State College

$1.89 slice — Alright Frankie, textbook NY flop, crisp bottom, crust is good. A little greasy though. Not as flavorful as I remember. It’s good pizza, just not the best I’ve ever had

Definitely a Football Pizza. Decent flop with a nice crisp crust. Not super flavorful but decent.

One bite