Brother's Pizza

Nice large NY slices. Always get the combo at lunch. You’ll even get a complimentary basket of bread sticks and sauce. Lunch staff is wonderful.

Lunch slice deal. Really good crisp, zero flop, and not greasy. Cheese and sauce don’t have a lot of flavor

Up there with Monte Carlo’s for best pie in State College

Bit plain. Cheese is basic. Sauce below average. Crust blah.

Good, above average NY style slice. Mild Sauce , good cheese, and a nice crispy crust.

Brothers pizza is the best pizza for you and me

BEST PIZZA. SERIOUSLY INSANE. SO GOOD. COME HERE.

Awesome.

Fucking amazing.

Very chewy dough with not much crisp. The za lacked sauce and was overwhelmingly cheesey. Big flop and pretty cheesy.

Low quality za with minimal flop and much to be desired in the sauce spectrum. Crust was hard as morning wood and failed to fold. Strength lied in the cheese but could not do much to pull it over a 4.

Crispy crust, good cheese. Would definitely order here again.

$2.25 slice — Alright, Frankie. Major flop, bottom was actually kind of soggy. The crust was crisp though and had a good taste. The sauce and cheese had nice flavor, but there were pieces of tomato skin in the sauce which I don’t really like. Decent pizza. I’d probably come back, but I’m not going out of my way to get it again.