chadt1/9/21, 6:15 p.m.
Always great pizza tastes like a meal in your mouth. Great sauce,cheese and crust. No flop, little greasy, solid pie
elyseparker1/9/21, 6:12 p.m.
No flop. Lots and lots of cheese. Thick dough. Good taste. Good pizza for football and drinking. Very very greasy. Overall good pizza and solid taste. Very filling.
james.ryan912/29/20, 1:11 a.m.
Can’t go wrong with good brothers pie simple but great. One of my favorite on the island
rustyd10/31/20, 4:09 p.m.
Square slice was Great. Dough was soft but crunchy. Sauce and Cheese perfect. Round slice was good. Great Dough just to thick and cheesy for me. Get the Square slice. You won’t be disappointed!!
thearcher7/30/20, 4:55 p.m.
Good old fashioned NY style pizza. The Sicilian is to die for though definitely get that one.
brianmatthew4/29/20, 5:41 p.m.
Haven’t had Brothers Pizza in many years. It was well worth the visit. I ate it as soon as I got in the car and I already wanna go back for more. The absolute best! 🍕
pizzadoc.jv3/13/20, 2:28 a.m.
Good slice. Good taste. Sauce very good. Good cheese. Good crust even though my slice had a slight burnt taste to it. Floppy. A little greasy. If it had more crisp and didnt flop, I could see a 7.9 score. Nice spot to grab a slice.
23 views•1 like
charles.sulse3/6/20, 6:24 p.m.
Sauce had no tang or flavor. Not enough crisp in the crust, but the cheese was very good. Basic football pizza
shimmertime932/27/20, 11:51 a.m.
Best square pie on Staten Island! The crust is thick, the sauce and cheese are fresh. Consistently excellent for over 40 years!
mr.saturdaynight2/13/20, 5:01 p.m.
No flop whatsoever. A bigger then average slice with a healthy amount of cheese and oil. The crust was crispy and the bottom had just enough burn to add to the crisp. The sauce was on the sweeter side but not overpowering. An all around nice mix of with the harder bottom and the softer dough softened by the sauce
matt.brown521/24/20, 12:30 a.m.
So far I’ve had 4 pizzas on the Island. This is my number 2. Good cheese consistency and the crust was on point. Damn good pie.
bkpizza16011/18/19, 3:38 a.m.
Hands down Brothers Sicilian is one of the best slices of pizza you can eat. It never disappoints !!
matthew.croley9/16/19, 1:41 a.m.
Square only: airy crust with good flavor, standout sauce, not as crazy cheesy as it looks in the pic. The sauce makes it special.
lennoll18/21/19, 4:57 p.m.
Really good slice, even if a bit on the heavy side. More greasy cheese than necessary. Nonetheless, I’d come back.
rob.ecker7/23/19, 4:06 p.m.
Great Pizza, sauce, cheese and crust no flop. Delicious sausage and peppers as well on the other side