Bucks Coal Fired Pizza

Great crust comes fast out of this coal fire oven! These guys are into their art. So much so that they actually appreciated looking at their regular pie as it came out. It did look good. Great pizza. If I had to make a critique, the sauce is slightly sweeter than I love but still didn’t take away from enjoying this pie.

Amazing everything I am a pizza fanatic. New Haven is the the pizza to be judged against and this is close. Crispy tasty and perfectly cooked. A little char.

Definitely worth the drive! Took the whole family yesterday and it was everyone’s favorite. Great pizza and great people!

Before the new recipe! I’m excited to try the new pie!

Great coal fired pie, the vibe, the taste, undercarriage, sauce, everything is ON POINT!

Best pizza in Florida. New Haven quality and better than most New Haven places that have been in business for 75+ years. Must try

Always amazing

8.2 all day. Good quality thin crust pizza. Can’t go wrong.

Great pie! Thin crust, great under carriage with cupped Ronis! Ate at the bar and watched some amazing looking varieties come out looking delicious! Super nice owner too!

Definitely recommend!! Love the char on the bottom ! One nice broke in stone to get that kind of Awesome CHAR ! Great Piece!

Amazing pizza with amazing people. Loved everything about Bucks. Had a great conversation with the owner and the staff. Was vacationing in Siesta Keys from California and had to make the 3 hour drive. Most come to this place if you are anywhere near.

Dave Portnoy is wrong

Forgot to take a picture of the pizza, but the tomato pie was really good

I can 110% recommend Bucks Coal Fire Pizza! Their BBQ wings, cooked perfectly in a cast-iron skillet, are an absolute must-try – so flavorful and delicious. And don't even get me started on the garlic knots; you get three per order, and they are just fantastic. Definitely a spot to check out!!!!!!!

Delicious & light. Great crisp and just a great experience all the way around. It reminded me a lot of sally’s from New Haven, CT. We had both a cheese and a tomato pie.

Excellent pizza. I could taste the individual components. The crust is very flavorful. This guy puts his heart and soul into the dough and it shows. Sauce is well-balanced with a garlic finish. Perfect amount of cheese. The 8.6 is on the Apizza (“abeetz”) scale. As you know, this is a more stringent scale by which Dave judges Neapolitan pizzas. On a regular scale, this place is a 9.4. Definitely going back. Atmosphere is a 10/10. Real people making great food.