Top Restaurants

Buffalo Pizza Project

Buffalo Pizza Project

1269 Erie Avenue, North Tonawanda, New York

Pizza Review

2 likes

justin.milazzo1 on One Bite Pizza App

justin.milazzo1

10/4/19 5:08 PM

I gotta say the pizza is pretty bad. It's way undercooked, super doughy, the sauce is awful and the cheese is nasty, like pizza hut kind of cheese. Even the pepperoni has a funny taste. I can honestly say there's nothing I like about this pizza. The guy who scored this a 8.1 should never be allowed to score pizza on this app again. I stopped here because he scored it a 8.1 and it really couldn't have been any more gross than what it was. 3.4 Frankie

Pizza Review

dublk10/13/25, 11:02 p.m.

6.0

Had potential but was undercooked and tasted likely hardly any sauce at all. Wings were undercooked a bit as well, I prefer at least a little crunch on them. Sauce for wings was good though.

Pizza Review

big.bite.ben6/21/21, 11:59 p.m.

6.9

Cheesy za- junction style of you remember it. Real thick crust and but it was rushed out as I showed up early.

Pizza Review

thepizzapolice7166/4/21, 5:08 p.m.

6.3

Super thick dough. Major flop!!! Has good crunch especially the crust. Really greasy !!!One slice is enough to fill you up. Tons of cheese and pepperoni (not always a good thing). Sauce is sweet and lots of it. Over all above average slice

Pizza Review

chris.haun1/3/21, 7:00 p.m.

7.3

Not a bad pie, a little doughy but a good under carriage! A little to greasy for my liking. I wouldn’t travel 20min for this pie but if I. Lived in the neighborhood this would be my go to spot.

Pizza Review

jim.mitri10/16/19, 5:15 p.m.

4.7

Got a slice and agreed to much cheese and to my opinion a bit under cooked made it very doughy sauce was average but a hearty slice filled me up

Pizza Review

dan.shantler8/22/19, 2:27 p.m.

8.1

Solid pie!!! Tangy sauce, good crust, requested a bit less cheese, which I highly recommend. My go to in North Tonawanda for now.