Not too greasy, sweet sauce, a little flop but not sloppy
pmw11/29/20, 12:56 a.m.
Regular slice - 6.1. Cheese was bland. Not greasy. Not enough sauce. Good clean crust. Could have held more sauce and a more flavorful/greasy cheese. Sicilian- 6.7 ample sauce. Cheese still bland but nice fluff on the crust.
sushiguy12/16/19, 7:00 p.m.
Nothing special. Too much cheese. Pizza and pinwheel not heated thoroughly.
mario.bruno3/24/19, 1:21 a.m.
First time trying, and I must say the pizza is good. Since moving to Bay Shore this is the third spot I tried. Sicilian square was above average and the sausage slice was also above average, it could have been a bit more well done. Garlic knots were good and the cup of sauce they give on the side is amazing.
julioerubioperez12/7/18, 12:36 a.m.
Pizza would have been a 6.5 without the topping!! Not much Flavor, needed a lot of garlic and Parmesan to kick some flavor!!
pizzaguy2.09/30/18, 5:30 p.m.
Airy crust with flop. Sweet sauce with a lot of cheese which made It a little greasy. Flavor got better as you ate more and more
pizzaslut39/30/18, 4:49 p.m.
Flavor was ok. Good amount of sauce, I hate pizza where you can’t taste sauce in every bite. Crust was light and airy but not crispy. More towards soft and doughy. Little greasy and lots of flop. Overall I would say 7s and up are reserved for pizza you would go out of your way for. This is right on the cusp. If you are in the area def stop and give it a shot