Café Carmela

Ordered the Maggs This is up there with Angelo’s south Philly. Great crust, sauce, flavor. Very good pizza

Phenomenal Sicilian style pizza…very flavorful tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, very fresh basil…this is topped with broccoli rabe and Italian sausage, which were crispy and delicious. Id personally like the basil leaves ripped into pieces but to each their own. Staff was amazing and cant wait to come back.

I’ve had every single one of their 5 plain pizza styles but the Maggs is the best in my opinion which is an American boy and Margherita (7.8) hybrid. Prov pie is 7.7 unless you love sharp prov. American boy is 8.1. Nonna 8.2 but the Maggs I’ll give a solid 8.3.

Excellent pie, very crispy and light. I think Dave low balled the score a little.

Tried a different pie this time, honestly some of the best I’ve ever had. I rank this one 4th best in all of Philly, only behind Pizza Shackamaxon, Angelo’s, and Pizzata Pizzeria. Cheesesteaks are top 4 in philly too.

Plain is a 7.3 and margarita is a 7.6 Cheesesteaks here are best in Philly. Don cheech with cooper sharp. 9.4 cheesesteak

Noni was delicious. Had a cheesesteak also it was very good. Top 10 maybe if the roll was crustier.

No time, has to be short review. Good, not great. Crust a bit soft. Overall quite nice.

Sauce and toppings very good can tell it’s fresh, needed to be done a little more floppy in the middle, the oregano on top did over power some slices.

A little on the salty side, but good mix of cheese and sauce, a good sauce, great crunch on the crust too

The pie was really good. This was the Maggs Pie. The Cheesesteaks were also really good. Not sure why Dave rated it so low, but Angelo’s much higher? While we still prefer Angelo’s, this place wasn’t that far behind! Bonus points because it’s actually a restaurant and not take out only. If you prefer this style, you won’t be disappointed….

Really nice pie. Dough is perfectly flavored and cooked. Nice and crispy, with a real wood fired flavor. Could do with a tad more cheese, but the sauce is also perfect. Solid pizza. Will impress a date.

Finally got here was close enough to give it a go. Great tasting pie crust tasted perfect and charred great just a little to thick for my liking. Cheese was a real winner and not the greasiness that was said to be. Could have used a touch more sauce that’s about it on this one really good stuff tho! Reminds me of a girl with a thick ass but no tits. And just like that mother to a prince this pizza sat all over my face.

Great crispy crust and not much flop. Really good cheese, but a little greasy. Quality pizza !

good pizza nice crisp cheese a little on greasy end but it was still delicious cheese steak was better imo