Cafe Gia

If looks and feel were the only rating criteria this would be a 9+. Perfect undercarriage and zero flop…but surprisingly zero crunch on every bite. Just lacked the crispness that I was excepting. Really a let down, because it was a flavorful slice. But worthy enough to be a local favorite.

Premium sauce..sauce is first and foremost the crust was a little tender in the midsection, but still delicious. Also had a nice layer of cheese that floated on the sauce which was some good sauce. I'm giving it a 7.8 for the sauce.. Check out their special slices too, Salad slices look stellar

Overall a great slice, nice crunch, sauce is sweet with a nice tang. ( preferred for me)

Fantastic just a bit greasy but great crisp

Zero flop....sauce was way too sweet. Dough needed more salt.

Put the review in the wrong place again....Good slice crunchy everywhere... light on the sauce but doesn't effect the enjoyment that much... cheese taste quality.... however the flop and grease really hinders this from being an elite slice.... really good though worth the trip

Could be a below average slice due to the social distancing and less people visiting restaurants, but the sauce was bland, the cheese was bland and the crust was bland.

Good Pizza, holds form, not to much flop. Overall good slice.

Plain slice: not too cheesy, sauce has good flavor; nice tang, thin crispy crust. Wouldn't drive out of my way for it, but would eat it anytime I'm in the area. 7.2 Bonus reviews Siciliano slice: not enough sauce, too much cheese, could see spices but couldn't taste them. 5.8 Dr. Pepper: 20oz and 2 liter bottle available, fountain pepper is good, not great but good)

Undercooked, soggy pizza. Not a fan, also not from the boondocks of long island so maybe NYC just has better pizza

Good pizza, crispy crust, good cheese. Solid pie overall.

Very good tasty pizza !

Real hearty flavor in the sauce great crunch in the dough overall a great gma slice Grandma Slice

Solid slice

I was told the Sicilian was great . I thought it was ok. Very doughy and sauce was mediocre.