About Cafe SiTALY
164 Yelp Reviews
daisy1bite8/10/21, 11:52 p.m.
a good sicilian pizza. could be crispier underneath and fluffier middle. but prob best around. However a bit too salty. Not sure but my guess was the cheese that they use.
tom.mc23/12/21, 10:21 p.m.
I have to give credit to my fellow pizza reviewers. Since downloading the app I have checked some of the places I’ve been and the scores are pretty much on point. That includes cafe Sitaly which I rated an 8.0 exactly as scored by the raters up to now. My score is a combo of two scores from the two pies I got. First. I had the crispino grandmas pie. That was an awesome pizza with a great garlic kick which I like and very fresh sauce and an awesome crust. I gave it an 8.2. The other one was there traditional pizza. Still very good but I gave that a 7.8. I am glad I found this place I live near by but never knew it was a pizza place until I got the one bite app.
ralph.papa9/16/20, 11:49 p.m.
This Granmas Crispino pie is the best thing around this area by far! A must try.
dennis.leahy8/30/20, 11:29 p.m.
Burned the hell out of my face. Good crisp, very good pie. The toppings were very good too.
nick.magnotta14/24/20, 5:42 p.m.
Best pizza on the area by FAR . Crisp crust , sauce and cheese blasting with flavor . Comparable to Angelos in south Philly .
sloppyc4/11/20, 7:06 p.m.
Too greasy but hardly any flop. Good crust though. Quality and quantity of pepperoni is A1. Grandma side is much better give it a 7.9, great flavor
jeff.edmiston5/9/19, 10:18 p.m.
Large cheese pizza. Extremely good crispy dough. Perfect amount of cheese and sauce. Highly recommend Cafe Sitaly pizza!
chris.barletto3/1/19, 9:41 p.m.
Gotta get the crispino grandma pizza give 45min for them to make best pizza in Delaware
bill.binder2/9/19, 11:28 p.m.
Small little hole in the wall great service. White pizza was fantastic and the classic cheese pizza was great with nice fluffy crunchy crust and light tomato sauce. Plenty of cheese to go around.
bossman6011/23/18, 8:36 p.m.
I grew up just outside of NYC, so I was spoiled with the best pizza in the world for most of my childhood. I’ve now lived in Delaware for the past 25 years and have searched all over for pizza places that can come close to real NY style pizza. I’ve found a handful over those 25 years, but this one is the best. Perfect thin crust w just a little crunch. Perfect sauce/cheese ratio and the sauce has a good tang. Not quite up to level of my favorite NY spots, but easily the best I’ve had in DE. Also, be sure to get a slice of Grand-mom’s pie (see photo). Somewhere between a classic thin crust and Sicilian. Really really good.