Calusa Pizza & Craft

A solid 7.9. I’d rate it higher than any pizza in the area. Really Nona Slice is the only pizza better than it around the Tampa Metropolitan that I’ve tasted. Minimal flop, but a little over done even if it was asked to be crispy. The dough is the culprit. Hard to mimic NY, but this does the best job in Tampa, even over Eddy and Sam’s.

Thin crispy and great with a beer!

I’ve been chasing this dragon of the best gas station pizza from my childhood back when I didn’t have shit. In the best way this is like that memory on steroids, PCP, BBL, whatever. I didn’t know what category it fell in but that feels appropriate. It’s fucking phenomenal pizza and they were accommodating with my tomato allergy because whatever god you believe in clearly fucking hates me

Went for the small regular cheese pizza n thought it was pretty good, might change the score after a well done Dave special order. Not that greasy, good crisp crunch and i think the cheese n sauce were traditional. Will be back for more Also got some bruschetta, was good. 6/8 pieces n half the small cheese after a pretty decent garlic knot they threw in. Few beers to boot 👍

This is a very well executed generic pizza. It’s hard to ignore the notion that there’s nothing handmade about this pie when you flip open the box and observe how inhumanly round it is. It is indeed cooked very well. So there is some crisp. The ratio of sauce cheese dough is correct. The ingredients themselves are all slightly above average. It’s not that there’s anything done wrong, it’s that everything can be done better. I’d be ecstatic if I was served this at chuckecheese, and this is better than the chains on a good day. All the fake impossibly high scores from people with 1 review really solidified this score for me at the very top of average.

Great quality options great pizza fresh ingredients

I lost my edging streak to this pie

Good slice. Quality ingredients. Great options!

Best pizza in Tampa bay!

The best pizza in town

Crispy, thin, sauce is special! That’s a review!

Good pizza. New place. Small thin crispy crust. Wish it had a little more sauce on pizza but over all good