I’m from Watertown and this pizzeria has been open for a while now. Serving up NY style pizza. I have had thinner NY style slices this one is close... $2.89 for a slice, it’s nice and crispy on the bottom, the crust is also light and crispy. It is one greasy pizza and there is a plentiful amount of cheese which tastes really fresh. Hints of oregano show through the sauce but there is such a small amount of it, I can’t rate it fairly. It definitely needs more sauce and with it, it would be in the 8’s. All of the flavor is in the cheese. It’s a decent, crispy slice in a pinch but for now it’s a 7.2
bigdickslices6/14/20, 5:29 p.m.
Slices look uninspiring at the counter, but became nicer to the eye after getting warmed up. The cheese and dough are good but the sauce is lacking flavor. Also I ate the slice sitting outside so I was harassed by seagulls throughout the duration of the review.
brittany.macey12/29/19, 8:37 p.m.
No flop, perfect undercarriage for my liking, definitely a great pie!
andrew.betz12/27/19, 6:02 p.m.
Best Pizza and Watertown, but nothing too special. Sauce could use some more tang, but the crust was cooked nicely.
travis.gebo11/9/19, 1:57 a.m.
Good Tang, chewy on the cheese. A little greasy for my taste. But definitely a good Sunday pie. Solid 7.1
15 views•0 likes
jaron.robinson11/4/19, 11:06 p.m.
Honestly if you’re looking for a great slice of pizza in the area Cams is the place great Football pizza
david.pappas9/7/19, 7:07 p.m.
Pizza was very good then crust sauce was very good I give it a 8.1
james.mullaney8/17/19, 5:40 p.m.
Best pizza in Watertown consistently good quality. A little pricey but there is no competition in the area that comes close. Crust is just right, sauce could use a little more pop, but the best in the North Country by a wide margin.
ken7/2/19, 9:50 p.m.
2nd pizza review with Kingston, Ontario kid, Dylan. Check out his review at the Pizza Stop in Rochester, NY.
7 views•2 likes
shawn.stephenson16/20/19, 7:21 p.m.
Probably the best old school NY pizza you are going to find in NNY the owners are great people and go out of there way to please you great place
josh.genter12/23/18, 7:44 p.m.
Pepperoni sucked. White pizza to die for. Good red pepper shakers which seems to be a rarity up here. Only thing that saved this place was the white pizza.
dylan.clarke12/8/18, 7:00 p.m.
Lot of flop. Good sauce. Decent cheese. Alittle on the greasy side but not too bad. It’s between a football pizza and a great pie. Crust was too soft for my taste. Next time Im going to ask for them to keep it in alittle longer to let the crust get more crispy.
bernie.bernhardt9/5/18, 9:28 p.m.
Good football pizza. One of the best in Watertown. Some NY flop, nice crust.
foldingslices9/2/18, 5:51 p.m.
All around solid pizza. Not too greasy, not too dry. Dining in feels like a classic pizza joint.