Cappy's Pizzeria

Very good pizza, the pepperoni really brings out the the flavor overall of the sauce. Top notch

Medium dish to perfection

Get real! You’re driving an hour for this pie! Trump is a chump!

This is a solid pie. Cheese and sauce both had a nice flavor. Even though I give this a 7.3 this would easily be a high 7’s to low 8’s for Portnoy just because this is the crunchiest pizza I’ve ever had. Plus the pizza had no flop and very little grease so I could see Dave going absolutely bananas for this pizza. Also this place has a really nice dining room and played only 60’s music while I dined so I recommend dining in instead of take out.

Great thin crunchy crust, solid cheese pie at a cool spot

Got a large NY style pie with pepperoni and basil. Very good texture, slight flop but a nice crunch. Sauce is tangy and tasty. Cheese was good as well. Love the place as well, will be back!

These scores are crazytown…but good Chicago deep dish if that’s your thing.

Exceeded my expectations. The sauce is very rich and flavorful. The crust cooked well done. Cheese was not too greasy. I will def be back

Chicago deep dish as close as it gets to my times in Chicago! This is the best pizza in St. Pete!

Best deep dish in St. Pete!

Great Pizza, Staff, Beer, Undercarriage, etc.

Alright Frankie....great tang on the sauce, also easy on the sauce which I’m a big proponent of, high quality cheese, and a pretty darn solid under carriage. Garlic Parm crust puts it into the 8’s. That’s a review

Average deep dish cheese pizza. The tomato sauce was excellent, the cheese was good, but there was something off about the dough...i couldn’t place my finger on it but it tasted like the dough wasn’t fresh if i had to guess. Restaurant is an old renovated home, so it literally has the feel of coming over someones home and them cooking for you. It’s a nice quaint vibe. I couldn’t decide between a 6.9 and a 7.1 so I went with a 7 flat. I also had to cut my own slices, which I thought was a little strange...first world problems. If you live in treasure island, fl this is the best pizza available for delivery via the seamless food app.

Fresh cheese pizza

Alright Frankie...Cappy’s St Pete. Can’t say it’s as good as the one in Tampa. This slice had serious flop and the cheese was all over the place. Would of liked the crust a bit crispier. I did like the sauce and fresh pepperoni. But need to keep this pie cooking longer.

Little flop. Great cheese. Light sauce. Good but not great pie

A lot of flop and a little greasy. It had very little sauce but tasted good.

Crispy , but I’m a fan of the deep dish at Cappy’s.

Did the Chicago style here. Cool neighborhood pizza joint. Quality pie.

Decent pizza!! Crust has a nice crunch with little to no flop & the sauce was tasty but was definitely lite. The cheese is above average so overall 6.8 #thatsareview

Great pizza, quality ingredients for sure, I wouldn’t say this is exactly NY style since it a little thicker than the NY standard but this is good stuff. Cheese was really good, high quality. Zero flop, very little sauce but it’s very tasty, crust is good with a nice chew to it. Very cool place and excellent service. 8.3 that’s a review!