Cappy's Seaside Pizza & Steaks

Solid beach pizza great undercarriage but still has a lot of flop. My personal favorite place on the island

Extremely greasy. Grease masks the taste - which actually might be good. Crust is “electric bite” too bad the grease makes the rest of the slice a sloppy mess that tastes below par.

Very in consistent place.....I have had slices in the 8’s and other times in the 5’s.....today was about average for here 6.7

Cold slice, not many positives, ordinary slice, terrible customer service

Score on the app is pretty high, I’m a little disappointed 🤷🏻‍♂️

Alright Frankie...the previous reviews got me excited, only for the big letdown. Dough was fresh, but it’s slightly criminal to have cornmeal on the crust, let’s be real. Sauce was bland, and cheese was mediocre as well. The thin crisp on a good portion kept the rating from falling even further.

One bite, everybody knows the rules...best pizza in cape May! Great flavor, great size, quality ingredients. My go to place in the city of Cape May.

Best pizza in Cape May I’ve ever had. Perfectly Thin still had a Crisp. Quality sauce and cheese. Wish I would’ve known about this place sooner. Everything else was really good as well. Overall 10 experience but to stick with the pizza rating I have to go a 9.2.