Served very warm in 3-4 minutes with medium flop and moderately crispy. There is a LOT of sauce that has zero tang or seasoning. It’s also very sweet. The cheese is better than average but oily and bland. There is also a LOT of cheese and the crust was okay at best. If they can improve their dough recipe, sauce / cheese ratio and improve the seasoning, this could hit the mid to high 7.0’s. Pro tip: ask for your slice extra hot, that additional 1-2 minutes will help.
dan.ratto10/17/20, 10:20 p.m.
Reviewing the plain slice. This, This right here. Is what I'm fucking talking about. 🥲 Your average NY slice of pizza. Pretty light, great crust. No flop. That sauce. Wow. Makes me miss Long Island. Love it.
pizza.keith2/24/20, 4:29 p.m.
Good crisp, Fantastic sauce a greasy on the cheese. That sauce is elite
pizzalife231/20/20, 5:10 p.m.
Every time I’m in croton I always stop here. And some times just purposely drive 40 minutes to come here. Very great pizza. Specialty pizzas are like nothing you’ve seen before
daniel.carroll9/25/19, 6:05 p.m.
Chicken scarpiello. Very good. Kinda greesy and I wish the chicken pieces were a little smaller
playoffbeard1912/20/18, 6:51 p.m.
Awesome selection when buying by the slices. So much to choose from (Chicken pesto & bbq chicken pictured)
lordblumby8/30/18, 10:50 p.m.
A little too small to be a football pizza, but a football pizza at heart. The sauce is sweet, the crust holds its own (no flop), and it's appropriately greasy. Been eating here for ~20 years, never disappointed
erik.blumberg8/30/18, 10:47 p.m.
Good, solid slice. No flop, a little greasy. Sauce is a bit sweet. Cheese is alright. Dependable, go-to slice.