Captain Pizza

Incredible pie - excellent crisp and the flavor on the sauce was astounding. Didn’t quite align with other scores for me but might be subjective, like my pizza a bit more doughy and the texture when biting through the slice was a bit too thin and seemed to be lacking cheese. All of this minor though otherwise the pie would have gotten above 8’s

Worth traveling for.

Absolutely outstanding.

Way too thin. Was expecting better. Sauce and crust were good, but some pieces too chewy. Love the old vhs movies inside. Too much hype on this one. Just pretty good.

Best pizza in the Merrimack Valley.

I'm sorry I didn't get a Pic of the pizza but i did get a Pic at the spot to prove it's legit Great pizza, very nice staff, met and exceeded expectations

I pre ordered for a 4:00pm pick up and pizza was ready by 3:55pm. Great staff and nice vibe. (90’s themed) to Dave’s point, it gets better with every bite.

Great crisp. Great flavor. Great service.

Used to be Captain Mediterranean. BUT THIS IS THE REAL DEAL!!!! Tiny menu but the pizza tastes like how you would imagine pizza in your childhood would taste like

Couldn’t wait to take the first bite. Just a phenomenal slice!

This pizza is the best around. This is even better than Bianchis before and after. I just hope I can get a pizza sometime soon in less than 2 hours! Congrats Garlic Breath !

Excellent New York style pie. Good crunch and perfect amount of cheese. Have to try a pepperoni and garlic pie!

Easily one of the best in the area. Friendly staff. Very good pizza.

Phenomenal pie and easily the best in the area. Always consistent. Nice little crunch to the bite and perfect thickness. Even the crust is delicious.

Yep! One bite audinn knows the rules. PORTNOY WAS HERE TODAY 🤯. I rushed over here after going to tripoli pizza of lawrence which he posted on his story, and after he just posted this on his story. Found some other followers at this location but of course, we were too late. BUT MAN, LETS KEEP OUR HOPES UP. WE WILL FIND HIM SOMEDAY. So, who knew I had this good of a slice this close to me?! Legendary crisp and the flavors of sauce and cheese are insane. Almost reminds me of Joanie's in Chelmsford but without that consistent crisp in every bite. So yeah, possibly the last community review before Portnoy posts his and the line gets slammed everyday. I can feel a good review coming from him. But yeah, super good slice that I will for sure be coming back to VERY frequently, like who knew I had this down the road of the auDinnBRUH!u and AUSJAC residency? So ya, 8.3, AUDINN OUT.

You get more than what you pay for. Curly pepperoni, great sauce and crunch. Not sloppy or soggy at all. I’ve had this pizza for take out by the box before and it travels well. The 90’s TMNT vibe is everything, but there are only two booths. The minimal menu allows for more focus on well sourced ingredients and pizzas done well! The owner is wicked nice!