If it had better dough/crust, I'd put it into the high 7's. The sauce and cheese are great. But the dough is too soft and bready. It also doesn't hold up the next day like a good NY style pie should. But it's ok in a pinch if you're at a nearby beach and don't want to get in the car to get a pizza.
Order now on Slice
Order Captain's Pizza & Sub
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
mattwhataguy7/9/21, 6:14 p.m.
Thin floppy greasy slice but it is loaded with flavor in the cheese! Better than it looks: Sneaky good 7.0
2 views•1 like
chris.carhart18/2/20, 3:15 a.m.
Honestly no idea why there’s so many bad reviews this pizza rocks
davidwillow8/2/20, 12:57 a.m.
Captains Pizza needs to walk the plank... just plain horrible Nothing else to say
lilmurpdo9/2/18, 5:05 a.m.
This pizza is such trash I no longer order from there. GO TO PONZETTI’S they are a solid 9.2