Caradaro Club Pizza

The Sopranos

Very good Milwaukee thin crust. 10 times better than the floppy pizza they serve at Balisteri’s. However. HOWEVER, the ordering system is archaic, the service is very slow and it’s not the most cleanliest of places. They can’t take calls and use the credit card machine at the same time like it’s fricken 1994 using your 14.4k dial up modem while brother Jimmy is talking to his dogfaced girlfriend and you just wanna chat with the bums on the local BBS. Synopsis: great pizza, the place and staff is old AF.

Good flavor but very greasy and floppy. For a thin crust shouldn’t be floppy. Cool little spot and is authentic but disappointed with the flop. Good ingredients tho

The owner’s a gem!

Great crisp, pretty undercarriage, no flop, fresh ingredients! Wally, the owner, is awesome. Must try pizza in Milwaukee!

Awesome thin crust pizza. Only thing at all negative is it’s on the greasy side but the taste is as good as it gets

Super thin crispy crust. Easily the best pizza in Milwaukee. If you think Balistreri’s is good, this is better!