Carbone's Pizza & Subs

Forgot to take a pic of my full slice, my bad that one is on me. Got a regular slice and not a sweet and wish I got the sweet. The sweet slice wasn’t all bad if i’m being honest but the regular well, doesn’t got much going for it. It was just a bad pizza slice that’s all i gotta say.

Aside from the fact I got run up on outside of the place this pizza was god awful. The sweet sauce slice was good, but that’s not the review. Tasted like a soupy greasy bread. Little to no flavor. Carbones is just a bad chain of pizza that is highly overrated. Some of the sloppiest pizza I’ve had grace my mouth. Bless my soul after eating this shit pizza. I once again feel dirty after eating a slice of pizza. I need to be cleansed. I might’ve contracted multiple communicable diseases from this. I wouldn’t feed this pizza to zoo animals.

Wish i was joking when I say a bunch of kids jumped on my car and wouldn’t get off until I drove off upon picking up this slice. To top off my expirence this pizza was absolutely horrific. Wouldn’t feed it to the wild gremlins that jumped on my car. Tasted like greese and piss

Very good pepperoni and old style Buffalo sauce. Crust was thinner, not doughy which was also done very well.

Some of the best pizza I’ve had in a while. If you’re in the Buffalo area and u don’t order this pizza… something is wrong with you. Great slice, great service, 10/10 recommended.

Tried sweet sauce and regular. Couldn’t decide which was better. Sweet was a little too sweet, regular needed a little herb assistance. Crust had a little crunch, nice undercarriage. More cheese than I like and kind of slid off. Pepperoni slightly charred.

Awesome pie! Little bit of flop. The sweet sauce is amazing with the garlic crust. One of the best pies I’ve had. Traditional Buffalo pizza. Phenomenal

Soft and kinda sloppy pizza. Been to most of not all Carbones locations and this is my least favorite.

Not bad, not great. Average sauce, too much cheese, floppy. Disappointed given the high reviews.

I like it more crispy for my taste. Solid pizza tho

Good flop and tang as well. Good pizza

Not that bad of a slice... burned my mouth. The two things that sets me off about it were the sauce and the grease.

Solid slice!!!!

On average a very solid slice, just very inconsistent. This pie was a little messy and had crazy heavy flop, but it tasted excellent.

Doughy and undercooked. Minimal bite in the crust. About halfway through the slice, I got this weird flavor that threw off my palate. The sauce is seasoned just enough to make it out of the “plain” category. Pepperoni tastes fresh and the cheese is okay. I’m not impressed with this slice and based on this experience it’s a 6.4 tops!

Pretty decent.

Everything about this pie is excellent

Personal Pickel Pizza with ranch based is absolutely amazing. Already ate 3 going on the 4th.

Good pizza and one of the staples of buffalo pizza, was almost hard to decide if they made it to the 8 club and they just made the cut, best part is flavorful sauce and handcut stick pepperoni solid pie, might wanna let her cool down though she can get a big messy