Carfagno's Main Street Pizzeria & Grille

Surprisingly light and fluffy. Long ride home, probably would have been even better right out of the oven. Little soupy in the middle though.

Best pizza in the area. Asked for it well done. Little to no flop, good crisp, good sauce to cheese ratio. Solid pie.

Pepperoni has some flop and a bit much grease. The sweetie pie was delicious and had zero flop! Great sauce and cheese mix on the sweetie pie. That's a legit 7.5. pepperoni takes the score down.

Decent crust. Sauce is good with a savory tang that’s not overpowering. Cheese is standard but well balanced with the sauce. Had a little bit more flop than usual. I’ve had excellent slices here before that I’d put at mid to upper 7s but this one was standard. Hence the score.

Solid Pizza. Cooked perfectly, zero flop and crispy. Cheese and Sauce ration spot on

Real solid piece of pizza. The crust isn’t overly thick, nor overly done. It stands up when you hold it and isn’t too doughy. You’ll notice the cheese flavor more than the sauce. This is a go-to pizza if you’re watching sports or having people over and need a no frills no surprises solid pizza. This is what I think of when I imagine pizza.

Perfectly cooked, delicious

Great pizza across the board, but the sweetie pie is fantastic. Also awesome staff!

Sweetie Pie Pizza: Sauce is sweet and delicious. Crust is firm but soft inside. Very little flop. Solid structure.

Good slice, little greasy. Flavor of cheese and sauce weren’t anything great.