Carlisle's Pizza Tavern

Literally the most amazing pizza ever, best crust, soft but crispy. Amazing

Best pizza I have had since leaving the NorthEast! 0 Flop.

Haven’t reviewed in a while. I’m sorry. I’m better than this. Been meaning to try this spot for quite some time, and I finally found a moment to give it a whirl. It’s as football pie as you can get, but one of the best I’ve had OTP. It’s what you want for a non-chain joint. Service was fantastic too. Cheers mate

I’ve been to Italy, Chicago, NY, I’ve had all types of pizza, this, THIS PIZZA was by far the best I have ever had. The crunch of the crust was a perfect balance to the inside of the dough. The ingredients were fresh and perfectly balanced and matched. The owner is so kind and the atmosphere is quaint with much character. This is a must taste pizza place!!

Crust is the perfect mix of chewy and crispy! Sauce has great flavor and the toppings are all good quality. Love this pizza so much!

Great structural integrity. SOLID cheese to pepperoni ratio. Overall amazing!

Super thin, super lite, and very crispy! This is our Thursday night spot! Dave needs to come to Roswell!

Very good pizza. Had a pretty sever flop. Overall very good.

Great pizza perfectly crispy, best in its class. Comparable to joes, did fara, and many other greats

Phenomenal pizza! Crispy crust, amazing ingredients. A little greasy but still on point.

Great pizza. NY style for sure

Very thin and crispy. Good cheese. Don’t know if I would call this neopolatin pizza, but NY style for sure!

Very thin with too little cheese. Decent taste, but needed lots of salt to give it good flavor.

Great pizza

Very good pizza for the area and for Georgia over all.

BBQ chicken pizza, great sauce and crispy crust. I’ll be back