This inside of this place is about as classic of a Central Jersey pizzeria as you can find. The pizza itself is not great, however, as the flavor is pretty underwhelming and the crust isn’t crunchy enough at all for my liking. With that being said, this place does have some other good food, and the people there are very nice.
Order now on Slice
Order Carlo's Pizza & Pasta
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
pizzamac15/18/21, 3:38 p.m.
Warmly greeted by the mask nazi upon walk-in. (People siting w/o mask lol). Lg slice, lots of flop, lots of cheese, zero crunch, not much flavor, a little greasy. Very average.
edgeofcrust4/20/21, 8:33 p.m.
Cheese falls right off, good sauce. Can’t go wrong, simple pizza
jazzo.sb2/14/21, 3:37 p.m.
I added my spices because I know how I like my slices. I also asked for well done. Good football pizza.
frankd.oneonly3/3/20, 2:16 a.m.
Cheese wasn't fully melted up at the top and the sauce was a little bit bland for my liking, which took the score down for me. but other then that it dough was cooked well, and I loved the crisp in the crust.
mr.saturdaynight2/15/20, 8:39 p.m.
No flop easy flip. The bottom was firm and not burnt at all. The crust was a little crispy but very doughy. The cheese and sauce were extremely mild and not packed with spices. All around it was very doughy and soft and very chewy.
sgtpet12/11/19, 12:30 a.m.
No flop, good crunch, sweet sauce , thin slice. Flavor is disappointing . Actually terrible Avoid this place
mattmcfeeley3/19/19, 8:22 p.m.
I was surprised about how good of a slice this was. Kind of caught me off guard. Jersey slice. Football pizza. Tasted great. Loved the ratio. Solid crisp.
matt.smith209/17/18, 10:06 p.m.
It’s not New York Pie Frankie, this is football pie, good crust, perfect mix of cheese and sauce. Crispy crust, with little grease drip. I’m going to go with a hard 6.8 Frankie, One Bite Everybody Knows The Rules