Carlo's Pizza

why does this place have such a high score 😭😭(〃ω〃)

Above average regular pie. Sauce is good, cheese is ok. Little thick on the dough. It’s a good football pie

The community score for this joint is way too high. It’s classic “football” pizza. Nothing more nothing less. Definitely better than the pizza spot down the road

OK, pizza review time. One bite everybody knows the rules! No flop, very nice undercarriage. The crust is crispy, nice cheese/ sauce ratio. Now I know what the picture looks like, the guy carrying the pizza didn't hold it straight after it came out of the oven. 9.5 listen it's great pie, great slice. That's a review. You want try some great pizza come to Carlos Pizzeria Middle Village, NY How is it, El Presidente hasn't heard of this place? I mean he was down the block at another pizzeria not to long ago. Carlos, Middle Village try it!

The Best pizza in NY, cheese, crust, crunch is perfect

Hey Goomba Johnny!!! Grabbed a Sicilian and regular slice at this popular Italian spot and came away less then impressed. Sicilian tasted pretty stale and very crunchy in a bad way. The regular slices had the oily top and too much of a tangy taste for my liking. If in the area, head to Rosa’s instead.

A very solid slice of pizza. Well done undercarriage with crisp. Good balance of sauce and cheese. Crust on point with a solid crunch on it. Overall a superior slice.

Excellent.

pizza so hot thought it was loud.. cheese tastes like chipca

Cheese is pretty good but the char taste and dough is what makes up for it and has a nice brick oven taste to it

Archetypal pizza. Not fancy but good. I don't think it's too oily but that could be because I got the oiliest slice of all them yesterday.

Nice amount of flop and grease. Strong sauce. Good stuff. Definitely recommended.

Great pizza. Needs more crisp and spice to the sauce to get in the 9’s

Went with the upside down at a usually strong pizza joint. Solid slice nice crisp good flavor

Good crispy slice, heavy on the cheese and a bit to oily🥶