Carlo's Pizza

Looks decent… nice and thin, but floppy… nothing popped unfortunately for me… all in all, just a slice… and that’s not a bad thing.. it’s still pizza :-)

Decent. There’s a bit of a Parmesan taste to the cheese which isn’t my thing. If that’s your thing this place is very solid.

About average not terrible not out of this world

Best pizza in Nassau

Carlo’s tomato??? Grabbed two slices here and was surprised to see how super thin they are. Super greasy and lots of tomato sauce on this one, minimal cheese. I just like my slices a little thicker and with flavor, so if that’s your thing, you should pass on this.

Very thin! Which is good. Tad greasy, but no flop. Crisp it up a bit. Almost like bar pie. Good taste.

Grilled chicken slice - first looks made my mouth water. Onions, tomato, galric and grilled chicken. Chicken was dry, underside of the dough was burnt, but not terrible. The tomato onion mix was tasty Vodka slice - same as the other slice, over cooked and underside burnt. The vodka sauce was delicious though. Boggles my mind how they charge the same $4.50 for a vodka slice as they do a chicken slice Lost a full point also because they charge $2.50 for a $.99 arizona bottle

It’s good pizza Frankie

Regular not as crispy as I would prefer but this sauce is absolutely delicious and the cheese goes perfectly with it. 8.5 Sicilan: nice and crispy tasty char on the bottom. This is one of the better sicilan slices in nassau county. 8.9 Margarita: again sauce is delicious and goes well with the fresh mozzarella. Cooked well done. Real good job 8.9

A great slice. Very tasty and thin Crust

Hit the spot after a long travel day. Greasy but good.

Really solid slice. A little greasy but I don’t mind. Coming here more often.

Great quality and taste. My style of pizza

Solid.

Bland sauce & cheese. Good crust.