Carlo's Pizza Shirley

Very floppy but good taste. Taste saved it from tanking in the mess.

Always best to get a fresh pie. They never fail to deliver good flavors

I tried the deep dish slice plain, and i’m not a fan of the sauce, it didn’t have a great taste. The cheese is kinda bland, I took my boyfriend there when he tried the plain sauce when he experienced Long Island pizza. The pizza is okay. Michael’s rating: 6.1

Pizza was decent. Stay away from the wings

Very floppy, greasy but not in a good way. Ovens at 1230 on a Wednesday obviously not clean and to hot

Bland, floppy... cheese is good but greasy.... if im really hungry and nothing else is open I'll go here

Slice was good. Chicken ricotta dough wasnt cooked through but okay.

They usually have great pizza but idk this time it was just ok

First slice had good cheese, very little flop, nice crust. I would have liked just a little more sauce but not bad at all....2nd slice was completely different. Very mushy... Inconsistent

Little flop, Source has some Tang not bad

Very good plain slice the sauce is very good always get it with the sesame crust Plain Slice

Very good pizza. Nice crust along with a good sauce.

Good football pizza. Has a lotta flop. But better than the Manorville location.

Solid cheese slice, would recommend the buffalo.