Carmel Brick Oven Pizza

Asked for well done, lot of flop and doughy. Vodka chicken pie. Cheese is probably in the 6s

Lasagna pie !

Served luke warm. Great undercarriage, good but not great sauce, and ok cheese. Crust was nice could have been higher if served at the proper temperature. Solid overall

Amazing sweet sauce. Friendly staff, solid char/crisp and great vibe.

Solid sauce, good crisp

Could of been in the oven a little longer. But a good slice

Solid local pies best around the lake

We’re here in good ol Carmel NY hanging out with my cousins. This place is right across from Deli Land where me and my cousins used to walk to all the time. Hit up the beach at Lake Carmel for a little sight seeing. A lot of good memories in this place. So they may have influenced my score a bit. But overall great pizza and great company with my family!

Carmella’s Cafe New Hartford. Solid slice... extremely thin but sauce was great

Pizza was so hot they must have used a blow torch. Never mind my mouth- I burnt up my damn fingers and 1/2 my lip stick to the crust. Ran across the street to use some strangers BBQ mitts so I could hold it to eat it. Very tasty. Crunchy great oil and cheese flavor . Headed to the burn unit to patch up my fingers Don’t eat that Frank PeePee pizza I’m danbury. Tastes like lemon. This place is awesome though. Had me 4 slices and ordered burn cream at rite aid.

Now I know it’s faux pas to split the pie on judgements but we’re only adding one classic ingredient and that’s meatball. It’s not going to change the continuity of the pie but JUST SLICE IT! Good pizza, will revisit.

This blew my D off as Dave would say. I walked in, sketched out as all F but the setup. The place was tiny and was like someone’s old house. I forged on and got a few slices. Never judge a book by its cover. The pizza was fantastic. I didn’t try many others in the area but there’s probably no need. This was top notch.