Carmelo's

Pretty tasty. A LOT of flop, but it sat in the box for a few minutes. Very good outer chew. Not hating on it at all.

Good pizza. Definitely worth your time!! Great wings too

Literal gas station pizza. Crust has some texture - a little crunch - without being crusty. No flop, but gets a little doughy toward the end. The bulky and cake-like thicc Sicilian was cold, but was overall slightly better (6.2 vs. 6.1). The sauce was pretty good on both slices.

I wanted to love this pizza place since it was highly rated by a local friend... - Sub-par sauce - Good but not great pepperoni taste - Inconsistent crust situation... a chewy base but crispy crust but crust tastes artificial. Not sure it’s worth the carbs 🤔 Side note: ordered a “margherita pizza” as well. Terrible. Definitely dropped the score of my review... red suave instead of garlic and olive oil. Too much tomato and flop.

This rating was given before the pepper and cheese was added

In my opinion, this is the best cheese pizza in St. Augustine. Don’t let the fact that it’s in a gas station fool you. Crispy crust, fresh ingredients, not much flip.

Good all around slice- cheese, sauce, and crisp

A decent amount of flop. The crust was better than I expected. The sauce was good, but the cheese was greasy. Good bar pie that was better than I expected after reheating the slice.

Frank boy more like fuck boy the pizza better than the other overly saucy stuff they call pizza around here no flop nice and crispy and good cheese too sauce isn’t to die for but good pie

Alright Frankie..... One bite, everybody knows the rules..... Not much flop, good crisp all the way to the end of the crust....good pizza....not great but pretty good. Decent sauce, average 'Grande" brand cheese they promote. Great football pizza. You wouldn't drive miles for it though. Solid "go to" pizza.

Half Margarita, Half Pepperoni & Mushrooms brick oven pie. Margarita side fresh, crisp zero flop. Mushroom & pepperoni big flop, lots of oil not as crispy. I liked the margarita side better.

Pretty good flavor, honestly this pizza has high 7’s potential; cheese and sauce were both really good, but not sure if just came on the wrong day or what but the crust had no crisp, dough was moderately floppy and still kinda doughy but seriously the flavor was there, maybe just need to ask for it well done next time.

Crispy crust, sweet sauce spread thin, top notch cheese - great single slice price $3 for cheese. 7.1 solid

Minimal Flop. Amazing Crust. Amazing Sauce. Hands down best, pizza I’ve had. Doesn’t matter what Bobby thinks, Eat a D*** Bobby.

A little flop Good sauce & cheese

Excellent slice. Crust perfect thickness and crispness. Great amount of cheese and delicious sauce. Highly recommended

Nice big slice. Don’t let the location fool you this is not gas station pizza.

best in st.aug