Carmelo's

NYC style in St. Augustine 👌🏻

Good NY style pizza by the slice. Affordable.

The crust was doughy not a whole lot of flavor.

Good overall pizza, a bit greasy. Good undercarriage. Dough has good crisp and chew, but not that al dente snap.

Carmelo’s St Augustine, FL

This is some big operation. I walked in 10:55am and they already prepped over 20 pies getting ready for the big rush. 1. Good signs were there being a policeman picking up lunch, which means they are liked by the local workers. Also the brick ovens were nice to see in use. 2. The pizza has a slight acidic taste to the sauce, but was not terrible. 3. The overall slice was very good. I won't say it "wowed" me to any extreme, but it is worth hitting up any time I come to town.

Perfect crisp, fresh ingredients, and absolutely 0 flop. Sauce was amazing.

Excellent pizza. Great sauce flavor and toppings.

Great under carriage. Good crisp. Highly recommend

Pretty solid, just too floppy for me needed to be cooked longer. Good taste.

Perfectly cooked! Great cheese, zesty sauce, great slice!

I enjoyed it so much I forgot to take a picture at first. Crispy crust (very little flop), yet it still melted in my mouth. I only ordered myself a 12 inch, but I look forward to ordering a larger one when I’m there with a bigger group. The pizza here was better than at their sister restaurant, 123 Burger house (which we also really like).

How does an Italian resto make it big time in a gas station in downtown st. Augustine? Seriously .. how? Pie ordered well done. Decent undercarriage but no crisp (-0.2). Sauce and cheese are consistent with your standard boardwalk / state fair slice. Bubbles were a nice accoutrement. Best of breed ‘za in STA besides Romano’s (7.1)

Good average slice

Pretty good pizza, it’s like your average pizza. If your local grab it. I just wouldn’t travel for it.

Basic Pizza. Too much flop. It would be a better score if it was crispier. May be better if asked for it well done.

Pretty tasty. A LOT of flop, but it sat in the box for a few minutes. Very good outer chew. Not hating on it at all.

Good pizza. Definitely worth your time!! Great wings too

Literal gas station pizza. Crust has some texture - a little crunch - without being crusty. No flop, but gets a little doughy toward the end. The bulky and cake-like thicc Sicilian was cold, but was overall slightly better (6.2 vs. 6.1). The sauce was pretty good on both slices.