Carmines NY Pizza Kitchen

Great crust and cheese

Not bad, good crisp and flavor.

So good, and had 0 flop

Tip to crust every part of this slice was excellent. A soft undercarriage that was still strong enough to support the body. Well seasoned sauce with a good pairing of cheeses. Crust was crispy on the outside and pillowy on the inside with a nice flavor. And all this on a reheated slice. Can’t imagine what a fresh one is like.

Used to be my favorite pizza on the Island. Just not the same anymore. Cheese has great flavor but it lacks sauce and the crust has zero crisp. Still a decent slice but there are better options 5 mins away.

The best NY style pizza on the island. However, you gotta ask for it “well done” as I too, am a fan of the crisp.

Extremely greasy, extremely salty, hella flop, crust is good!

Solid slice. Excellent crust, sauce and cheese.

👍

Indeed Ny style. Burned roof of my mouth but continued on.

Delicious crust. Great sauce. All around great slice

Good sauce, slightly undercooked, solid 7 if its slightly crisper.