Carmines Pie House

First off the Pizza had amazing crust. Good crispy light feel with no flop. I’m a big sauce person and that was lacking a bit for me so I had to give it a 7.3. Still better pizza than anywhere else around Jax but could be better too. The wings were easily a 10 though. If you go here and like wings, order them, you won’t regret it!

NY style review. Not bad, but the crust needs work. I'm not getting much flavor at all. If they could do a 2-3 day fermentation this could be a lot better. The night before rise isn't enough.

Very good pizza. Light, not a ton of grease, and the sauce was great.

Best Chicago Pizza around

Followed the one bite rule. Sauce has good flavor, cheese is delish, and the pizza had a good flop. Only reason for not a perfect score is that the crust was a little thicker than I would like from a New York pizza but it tasted so good it didn’t matter that much.

Damn good pizza. The place is awesome. I'll drive across town for that.

This was mid at best Crust was a bit too floppy, too much grease, and the cheese was too much. There is potential here and I did kinda like it (ate 2 slices which is a lot for me) but it just doesn’t really live up to my expectations. Overall, decent Florida pizza but not great.

Great crisp and the dough is good. Zero flop which I like. The cheese tastes fresh but the sauce lacks something. Not sure what but it doesn’t stand out. Still might be my favorite pizza in Jacksonville so far.

That’s an 8.1 Frankie. Minimal flop, tasty sauce, excellent amount of cheese. Now that’s a review.

Decent slice, a little too thin for my liking. Sauce isn’t great. Good enough to give it a try.

Solid slice, very crisp and tangy sauce. Would recommend

One best pizza pie you’ll find in Jacksonville, everybody knows the rules. Great New York style pie, best I’ve found in the area. Little bit of flop with great crust. NJ native approved.

Very good meat pizza great flavor. Love the chicken on it. Only been wish the crust was a little crisper.

Good. But just not a fan of getting new cheese on top of cheese. Deep dish was good, recommend and possibly saved this score.

Lots of flop.... lots of grease.... meat toppings didn’t have a lot of flavor... the crust alone got this pizza to a 6.0 ... cool spot, pizza is ok... not gonna write home about it

I got the NY style. It's just above cafeteria pizza. Maybe their Chicago style is better.

Gotta be honest here… not the best slice I've ever had. TONS of flop, tons of grease. Not the most flavorful pizza either. It's a good slice, but it's not in the "great" tier. Would come here again tho

Greasy

Alright Frankie... out here on the corner of eh Forbes. It’s a good slice. Classic flop, a little soft in the middle but overall a solid 7.3. Would go back

I went with the deep dish and it was amazing. crust was thick crispy and not a oz of Grease, the sauce is flavorful and the cheese is stringy

Overall good pie, crust is slightly thick and soft, could definitely have been fluffier.

Quality New York slice, while talking to the server found that the original owner was from New York and had a shop there, got it right !

Quality