Order now on Slice
Order Carmine's Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
thebrocksays5/6/22, 12:38 a.m.
Best crust I've had yet. Sauce was excellent too. Many other great slices here!
johnnykong1293/9/22, 6:02 a.m.
Was gonna try the Barstool 7.8 rated cheese slice but the pepperoni tomato square was just so good looking with all those crispy mouthwatering pepperoni cups that I just had to go for it.....and boy am I glad I did as the slice tasted as great as it looked. Each bite was filled with an explosion of the plentiful "roni" goodness. The balanced combination of the saltiness of the pepperoni and sweetness of the sauce with the soft firm crust gives this slice a well deserved 8.4
goblue_8458/15/21, 7:08 p.m.
Good quality slice with fresh mozzarella. Slightly floppy but the Yankee memorabilia in the restaurant solidified this eight-range score. Note, a better slice than Tony’s across the street (even though Prez disagrees).
delicious_mike4/28/21, 2:10 a.m.
Very floppy, good sauce and crust. I thought Tony’s across the street was better.
motelman1/11/21, 2:51 a.m.
Great fresh slice. Didn’t try the regular slice but the pepperoni is no joke. Doesn’t make the 8s but it an excellent slice.
janis1/3/21, 5:22 p.m.
Cheese slice. Was a pretty good slice cheese and sauce needed a little something, like a kick or sweeter
ryan.rutherford8/7/20, 6:34 a.m.
The picture doesn’t really do it justice but there is an abundance of grease drowning this pie. After lots of dabbing with paper towels, you can see the cheese has a creamy texture; it’s just swimming in oil and the taste is completely overpowered. The sauce is very basic, lacking in flavor, nothing special. This all rests on top of somewhat thick dough, with minimal floppage, and a fairly crispy crust. Much like Tony’s across the street from this joint, it’s rated way too high. Dave was in a really good mood when he gave out his inflated score and many of his followers have followed suit. I assure you this a very average and mostly forgettable New York pizza.
ja420ck11/25/19, 10:42 p.m.
average slice. thick outer crust. counter service was awesome at 10pm. served its purpose as a pre-show snack.
andrew.kanevsky10/9/19, 5:47 p.m.
Looked better than it was. That said, it was very good. Better than the regular, round slice.
eric.john29/19/19, 5:23 p.m.
Average slice. As usual, the hype didn’t live up to reality. The upside down Sicilian is a 5.8
ondre7/19/19, 5:53 p.m.
The inside of this place was awesome. Decked out in Yankees memorabilia. Really cool bar inside too. Pizza was pretty decent. Very greasy which I hate. Cheese was on point and that crust was crunchy was good char but doughy at the same time. Sauce was average
alexjaroscak7/13/19, 1:20 a.m.
Hadn’t even taken a bite and already was pissed. What kind of service is this? Dave Portnoy would not approve if he had gotten this..