Carmine's Pizzeria

From Central NJ and been in DFW. Couple years.... So far this has been the closest to pizza from home I've tried yet. Solid football pie Will be returning

If I had got a whole pie it would have been higher. Really good cheese and sauce. Good undercarriage. Next time I’m ordering a fresh pie!

Above average NY style pizza good crisp solid cheese great service worth a drive if you’re doing the Dallas pizza tour

Good pie dor dallas

Great pizza, I believe it’s way better than New York pizza. Will definitely come back to Addison Texas for this pizza.

Pizza looks great as far as a New York style! Undercarriage and crust is crispy! Had the perfect amount of sauce a d cheese not greasy at all! The staff behind the counter really made it seem like a stepped in a New York pizzeria!

Great thin sliced bar pie

Review is for the pepperoni only.....nice color on the crust and a good amount of pepperoni on each slice. They went light on the pizza sauce, which I am not a fan of, and the sauce didn’t have a whole lot of tang to it. The undercarriage is really nice, and the cheese taste nice and fresh, a bit oily but not too bad. Overall a good football pizza.

One bite everybody knows the rules, solid pie,football pizza.

Lot of flop but good flavor and good for kids.

Very standard pizza. Nothing really exceptional about it. Zero flop, nice crisp. Average pizza

Classic New York style. No flop. Crust was a bit chewy, but probably would've been better fresh out of the oven.

No flavor and I had a supreme. Crispy though..

Well done pizza, not much else to say

Crust lacking in flavor, cheese on point, sauce needs a little more zing. Decent pizza would come back, but only after they opened like I did now. I could see them having pizza sitting out for while and just reheating. Decent score for decent pizza.

Always reliable solid review by my kiddo

Carmine’s super OG Italian pizzeria

Classic place that has meant so much to so many. Tons of locals grew up at this place. Really good solid pizza by the slice or by the pie. Guys working here are so good and welcoming.

Good slice flavor crust. Lite on the sauce which I don’t like. Isn’t east coast pizza, though.