Carminuccio's Pizza & Subs

Slices are huge!! Cheese and dough taste phenomenal! The sauce is sometimes inconsistent, but when it’s right it’s delicious!

A little too much flop but overall a great pizza.

Great taste, good crisp, minimal flop

great cheese, great service. a bit pricey, but probably the best pizza in CT I've had excluding New Haven style or Big Y

Best pizza, great crust, tasty sauce, and best toppings are offered!

Really good slice. Extra large, good flop, tasty sauce. This is one of my local spots. It is well known that individual slices are better than buying a full pie.

Slices are HUGE! Didn’t have time for a fresh pie but a couple quick slices was enough to know this place is good!

Very light pie, by that meaning sauce. Good crust and cheese.

Solid undercarriage. Good crisp and sauce. Would order again if it wasn’t $30 a large cheese!!

Great pizza, I grew up on the stuff and will forever be the best pizza in Connecticut!

quality football pizza 🏈🍕 crispy crust with a good undercarriage crust, however, the only underside is how expensive it is 🤭 but cant go wrong with this ‘za!!

Probably the best crust in the area and a great looking pizza when you open the box.Where it falls short is in the sourness of the cheese. That doesn’t mean it’s a bad pizza but when you state you’re the #10 pizza in the USA one expects a pizza that will compete with the new Haven giants of the pizza world. I would go back and try a fresh mozzarella pie. It’s also a very expensive pie.

1 cheese slice, 11:45am on a Tuesday, $3.75 Pros: Tasty slice, fair amount of crisp resulting in just a slight amount of flop. Undercarriage has little hits of char. Cons: No coastline, my favorite part of a slice. Sauce runs out near the crust. A little pricey for a slice but it's a lot of pizza Verdict: It's a big-un. Pretty good slice here, satisfied with the purchase.

Who would have thought peas work on a pizza! Tried the plain cheese the other day than this today. Not sure why they have a score so low. It's a solid 7.9!

Very bland. Crust is mediocre but has great crunch. (The only reason it’s above a 3) Sauce and cheese had no taste. Was missing the “zest” that a pizza should have. Very disappointed. Was expecting much more out of a pizzeria with such a magnificent name. 3.1 that’s a review.

Solid slice

Rough Crowd