Caruso's Pizzeria

Was excellent crust was great

The GOAT pizza. Best pizza in Lancaster, hands down

Patty doesn’t know what he’s talking about

A little on the saucy side, but overall a very nice slice of pie. Crust was a little too crisp, may have been in for a bit too long. Over a solid 7.2 score.

Good crisp. Tangy sauce .. the second best Caruso’s pizzeria .. Prices went up a bit here .. Go Giants Boo Eagles

Caruso’s Lancaster Pa. Fruitville pike location. Delivered in unique condition. Asked for well done.... But whatever, I’m not mad. Sauce is sweet!just the way I like it. Good sauce/cheese ratio. I could do with slightly less grease. Nothing special but overall a solid pie. 6.7

Sweet Sauce... Thin crust... Floppy... Quality hometown pizza

Out of expectations for a Buffalo chicken slice Carusos is subpar. Chicken was rubbery, Hot sauce was minimal, and the “blue cheese” didn’t have any blue cheese in it. Crust was good, and we overall like the plane slice better.

Good pizza all around. Cheese is kinda dark but crispy crust!

The sauce really overtakes the pie. Great crispy crust, lovely undercarriage. Just a little too much sauce for me. Still a great pie.

The sauce was weak and had a strange flavor and it was like grease city

The cheese and crust are very good. It could use a little more sauce for my taste. But, good tasting.

Good crispy crust, could use more sauce. No Lancaster Flop. Skewed rating (ate after it chilled down) #LateToTheParty

Very good slice not a lot of flop and not too greasy