Casa Nostra

We ate in for dinner. You can get a small size pie in the dining room during dinner time. Regular appetizers were about $15 a piece. However, we ordered the fatty which was about $17 for our appetizer. This small pie came (about 12”) with pepperoni, meatballs, bacon, and sausage. It was crispy, loaded with toppings, and just enough cheese. It was cooked in a regular pizza oven, however, when the weather gets nice on the outside patio. They have a woodfired pizza oven that we would like to come back and try a pie out of there as well. We think the appetizers were over priced, and therefore this pizza was over priced by a couple dollars but it was very good. We would definitely try takeout pie from the joint.

Red and White pie was superb. It way ups a regular cheese pie with ricotta, fresh basil and great tasting herbs. Medium-thin crust was soft with nice crisp. Added gourmet mushrooms for $2. Has an adjacent restaurant with excellent food. Both well worth the trip.

This review is only for the plain slice. Good sauce, vinegary and tangy. Cheese blend was OK. Pizza was nice and crispy. This was good but not over the top. This place has the absolute worst type of napkins that feel horrible on your hands. I didn’t hold that against them.

🍕 large Neapolitan 💰 20 bucks 🤔 they really got the dough down. Perfectly crispy crust (not burnt but no flop). My only reasoning for the lower score is the sauce just isn’t as tangy or flavorful as some others / my preference. Overall great pizza though

Great Brooklyn pie.. super crisp, great char, zero flop. Great flavor. A little skimp on the toppings but no regrets. That's a review.

Hmmmm 8.1 or 7.9 well I went w the 7.9 something was missing on the sauce for me but the crust is the star ⭐️ ⭐️of this show hence the under carriage pic was beyond great. 5 mins later still crunchy. When I walked in they had slices and looked nothing like the pies I saw on One Bite. I showed him the pic and the 🍕 guy says take out is made as an upside down pizza but same ingredients as the slices . Was not the same no way make sure you get the pie!! Could eat everyday for rest of life and be happy.

What a hidden gem. We Love this place. Beautiful char, no flop, undercarriage and crisp excellent, sauce just right Mozzarella fresh and house made. Delicious It's making me hungry.

Definitely the best in this area. Thin with crunch—not burnt. Sauce and cheese are perfect! Highly recommend!