Cascarino's

Okay Slice. Burnt Crust is a big no no for me. Usually theyre better but this time it was disappointing. Better when you go in there to eat, than delivering.

I know why this has been the best of the valley! Omg😍

Voted best pizza in the Hudson Valley 4 of the last 5 years for a reason. Thin, crispy, no flop... Also the best grandma pie I've ever had!

Come on Dave come on by!

Classic New York-style pizza— the best in the Hudson Valley and my hometown pizza joint. Nice crisp—a little flop, good undercarriage, and delicious sauce! The best pizza sauce in the area and the best ingredients, hands down! Great overall flavor, with a little hometown nostalgia for me. Easy 9! Get here, David!

Overall my favorite place. Voted best into the Hudson valley in 2021 2022 and 2024

Great taste. No flop. Good cheese. I wouldn’t mind it a bit thinner crust but for sure one of the best in Orange County.

No flop, little greasy but crunchy. I was very impressed.

Sweet sauce something different

Good flavor in sauce. Didn’t blow me out of the water. Might have been better if I ate it there and didn’t have it delivered

Sauce was tasty wish the slice was a little warmer. Overall slice was just above average.

Simple, tasty, no flop, 6.9 sex