Caserta Pizzeria

I can understand why it is a local favorite. Simplicity defined, not quite Sicilian but good crisp crust and pretty sure just crushed tomatoes not a sauce— no garlic flavor and def no oregano. I will go back next time in Providence. We got there early Saturday evening before the crowds going to Providence Friars college hoops game. We also got mushroom and black olive pie which was also good . Interesting to note if u want meat toppings— all they have is pepperoni !

Love the sauce

Very good! If it was a little crispier easy 8.1

Providence has some very diverse styles of pizza, particularly this rectangular pie from Caserta’s that appears to be a cheesy, thinner version of Sicilian pizza, like a non-traditional grandma style pie without the basil and garlic. The texture and taste is somewhat unique, very different from traditional round football pizza, more similar to a Greek style pie. The cheese is super thick and stringy, definitely gives off Greek style blend vibes. The sauce is splotchy atop the cheese but spread underneath as well. Sweet and tasty, the sauce certainly pops, bursting with flavor, easily the star of the pie, making up for the average-tasting dough and cheese. The dough is decently crispy, fluffy in the middle with a solidly firm undercarriage, along with a buttery crunchy crust, like a combo of Sicilian and Greek style crust. The thickness of the dough and cheese make this a rather heavy pie. Despite being an Italian restaurant, this really tastes like Greek pizza, only better. While not my preference, this is a quality “change of pace” pie, a break from standard football & Neapolitan style pizza. If you’re in Providence, this is certainly worth trying; but I’m not traveling long distances specifically for this pizza.

Good reco. Lived up to expectations.

Solid crunch, great sauce and cheese. Love how the sauce goes to the end. No flop, bottom thicker than normal.

Got better with every bite! Very robust sauce. One pie fed the whole family. The sauce is the boss.

Very good! The crust is thick and fresh, the cheese is awesome, the sauce is amazing, you can’t go wrong here. I heard the stuffed spinach “Wimpy Skippy” is great so I’ll have to try that next time. Definitely stop here if you are in Providence!!!

Enjoyed this a lot. Nice crust.

Great pull on the cheese, tremendous dough, light airy crust. Good sauce. Could have used a little more crisp to get even higher. Still great Pizza

Great sauce, bread, and crust, not too greasy but pepperoni could be cooked a little more

Okay, this is the closest New York style Sicilian that I’ve had outside of New York. Very good, very reliable Rhode Island Pizza. The prices are good too.

The sauce is the best part.

Square pizza here.. would be one of my favorite styles to get but this one just fell a little short. Really liked the sauce the undercarriage was just a little hard and chewy. Will give this place another shot tho.

Very good flavor kinda like a silcian good sauce and chesse . No crisp or flop