Casey's Pizza & Sub Shop

Had high hopes for this place as most of the reviews were great. Very disappointed in the Za, almost soupy in the middle there was so much sauce. Super floppy and very bland flavour. Ordered a “thin crust” got a bready almost bakery style crust. Apps were good though and should have realized we were the only ones in a busy place that actually ordered the pizza.

Didn’t get a chance to take a pic fresh so it’s cold but an amazing pizza good crisp no flop amazing pizza 9.3

Yum

Plain cheese pizza. Heavy on the cheese. Mild flop. Longer cook time would have made it better. Decent pizza.

Plain cheese. Medium flop. Too much cheese. Bland sauce. Still a good pie.

Great Pizza

Got the typical Pep, Sausage, Basil and Cheese. Very cheesy, nice crisp not to greasy and solid under carrige. Would order again for sure! Loved the flavored crust! Thinking that's what put it in the 8's.

White out pizza. Love the flavor and texture. Crust is crispy.

Crispy crust. Too heavy on the cheese. Sauce is on the sweeter side.

Really cheesy, sauce is sweet, little bland to me. Good dough and crust.

Good place. Pizza is a little cheesy. Ok.

Pizza looked the part, unfortunately the taste wasn’t all there. 3rd degree burn on the roof of my mouth from all the grease on top. Crust was crunchy but not all that flavourful. Pepperoni seemed cheap. Not sure what all the hype is surrounding this pie. Mediocre at best. Thats a review.

White Out.

I know it’s fancy pizza but it’s a good pizza

One of the best single slices in town.