Served in about 4-5 minutes, very hot and a very oily. A little Yonkers flop and a nice cook on the crust. The mozzarella is high quality and there is very little sauce but it has good tang. This would have touched the low 8’s if it weren’t so oily. This is a top 5 slice and definitely worth the visit. The slice is a little too thick for me to call this a football slice, but hot damn you aren’t going to find a better slice within a 5 mile radius!!!
frank.reese7/12/19, 4:18 p.m.
Tiny bit of Westchester flop. Little greasy. Good overall taste. Nice football pizza. Throw on a bit more sauce and this could be high 7’s. Low 8.
gene.anthony10/12/18, 5:54 p.m.
The Sicilian Marinara slice here at Catania’s is a must have. The sweetness of the sauce balances perfectly to the bite of the garlic cheese blend. Also recommend a veal/pepper calzone on the side to accompany it