Top Restaurants

Catania's Pizza

Catania's Pizza

1821 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY

Pizza Review

0 likes

cjaquilino on One Bite Pizza App

cjaquilino

9/11/21 1:55 AM

$3 gas oven slice on a Friday night. Had this right before Benvenuto's II. This is nearly a whole point better, though I had to deduct a bit because my slice is wonky. Crust is light, pliable, and even a bit airy. It was mediumly browned on the bottom. Solid crust. Though the end's way too big. More cheese and sauce could've gone to that edge. Sauce? Just the right hint of oregano and a bit of garlic too. A light, thin sauce. Wish there was more though. Cheese? Diet amount of cheese on it. Not greasy. Salty. Pretty good. Not one review has mentioned this but they also do ***wood fired*** personal pies. Don't see any pictures of them here or online. Definitely coming back for that.

Order Catania's Pizza

Hungry? Order right now on Slice

Order now on Slice

Pizza Review

bigdaddytom8710/25/23, 11:47 p.m.

8.3

I used the Doordash app to place a pickup order for this beautiful wood fired pie you see here, and I had the option to have parm cheese, oregano and red pepper applied during cooking, which I gladly accepted. The red pepper made the shit spicy but I fucking loved it!! A little bit of flop at the tip keeps this out the 9s.

Pizza Review

michael.caterino6/16/23, 5:22 p.m.

9.7

Mussles on pizza . The phone didn’t eat first excellent . 9.7

Pizza Review

rg717/14/22, 3:29 p.m.

7.3

A bit doughy but very good sauce and cheese. No flop

Pizza Review

anthony.grandinetti7/2/22, 4:48 p.m.

6.5

Pizza Review

tobeymaguire9/6/21, 5:34 p.m.

4.2

My stupid wife ate up all the gabagool at home so when I passed Catania’s I was feeling relieved. Unfortunately, my bad day got even worse. Tough, stale crust, bad sauce, a burnt smell. This is BAD football pizza. Almost zero gusto. The cheese had a shred of flavor, had it not I would’ve scored in the 3’s. When the crust, the very foundation of your pizza, is stale you’re gonna have a bad day. This slice was 100% left out overnight.

Pizza Review

branthebroken5/22/21, 11:36 p.m.

5.9

Little too greasy, football pizza for sure

Pizza Review

brian.slice5/7/21, 9:43 p.m.

8.2

Best pizza around hands down! Order a large wood fired thin crust and do yourself a favor and eat it in house.

Pizza Review

jtc7/23/20, 2:08 a.m.

7.7

Solid thin Slice....Mini Calzones are really good also....gotta do a pie next time

Pizza Review

bart.sangiuolo5/4/20, 12:05 a.m.

6.4

Pizza Review

hvpizzaking8/14/19, 6:10 p.m.

7.9

Very solid, great crust, nice oils, great cheese, nice crisp, and a nice sauce. Just wish there was

Pizza Review

danielle.payne7/30/19, 9:30 p.m.

5.3

Sausage pie. Could use more cheese. When they first opened they were great with the ratio of cheese to toppings now it’s slacking.

Pizza Review

mr.mozzerella5/15/19, 8:40 p.m.

5.8

Medium flop, a little oily. Almost no sauce on the slice. Way too much dough in the crust. Decent ingredients with no major flavor dominating. The bottom was a bit too “charred”. Avoid the slice, maybe the pie is better?

Pizza Review

bill.gallagher3/19/19, 11:18 p.m.

8.5

Thin airy crust, sauce with a little zest and good cheese without too much grease. All done in a wood fired grill. Definitely the best pizza in the area, my new go to!

Pizza Review

john.wenk2/26/19, 9:52 p.m.

8.3

Best pizza in the area. Good doughy crust with fresh ingredients.

Pizza Review

ving103112/28/18, 6:32 p.m.

6.8

Solid cheese slice good crust good cheese. Sicilian slice is 9.2 easy.

Pizza Review

ryanallday12/14/18, 12:56 a.m.

8.1

Excellent wood fired pizza, get a pie, not a slice.

Pizza Review

joeyv12/5/18, 9:16 p.m.

6.1

Needed a little more seasoning and a little greasy. Sicilian slice was excellent and if I had to rate it would be 8.4 for Sicilian.

Pizza Review

pizzascientist11/26/18, 5:38 p.m.

8.2

Head and shoulders better than its competition in this area. Great crisp, oils, cheese, sauce, everything. Blandish crust is the only deduction. Excellent.