Catch-a-Fire Pizza - Blue Ash

Very greasy, very floppy, the pepperoni dominates the entire pizza. I got their cornerstone pizza that is at the top of their menu. The crust was nice. I was expecting a lot more from what is seen as an 8 on this app. I think if I fry it in a frying pan when I get home it'll be a 6.

Should have gotten just mozzarella and provolone cheese.besides the four cheese

Pretty well done. Niece little bar restaurant. Wood fire I believe. Regular cheese pizza has four cheeses. That is where they lost me a bit. I think it is the Asiago, but an tang to the pie that I don’t love. Overall really good but a little different.

Large Cheese Pie - $21.99. I’ve been wanting to try this place for a really long time. Absolutely fantastic. Wood burning oven really shows on that crust. Cheese, sauce and crust was excellent. A little greasy but this old New York Boy loves his grease. Fuck yeah I’m coming back!

Very cool looking spot. Crust and under carriage was very nice and charred but the cheese was so soupy. I think it could be a lot better and a much higher score but…. *Service was not good. She rang in wrong pizza, no refills and wrong size Togo boxes.

Some of the better pizza in Cincinnati. Consistently good here and at their Madtree location. Excellent char and bake, very little flop, good crisp, ever so slightly greasy, fancy cheese blend is a tad too much for my taste but good flavor.

What a great atmosphere. Sat at the bar and had amazing service from both bar tenders. We started with the Nati Bites which were perfect with the beer cheese and spicy mustard. As for pizza the four of us shared a large One Love which was $18. The sauce is incredibly fresh and you can taste the garlic. The dough is thin and chewy but the crust could have used another minute to crisp up. Next time we will order it well done but the way it was tonight the wife and I agreed on a 7.8. We drove 30 minutes to get there and because of the atmosphere and great service we will absolutely be going back again.

Nice zing to the sauce, but crust is a little too chewy. Great atmosphere and service.

Good sauce. Good cheese. Chewy undercooked crust. Extremely disappointed

Beat pizza I’ve had in Cincinnati.

Better this time than last it’s so thin and so good