Celestino's New York Pizza

7.6. Very good pizza. Will be coming back.

Looked good. Very disappointed. Bland sauce. Burnt crust. Cheap pepperoni. Scorching hot. Not much flavor. First sub 5 score I have given.

Crispy, Tang, Dusty Fingers, Good Cheese,

One bite, everybody knows the rules. Lot of flop, pretty bland sauce and cheese, not greasy, definitely college pizza.

Good size...a little flop...Good be crispier...Good go to spot for a slice

looks like i had a little audience watching from inside. solid slice of za. it’s been better on different days - no slice of pizza is the same. could use a littttttle more sauce. not good enough to skip out on ranch. could use some ranch if you’re a ranch guy. everyone knows the rules xoxo

Best pizza in Chico!

If you want Celestino's, go to the east ave location because this pizza stinks

Exploring Chico, and there’s no better way to learn about a city than by the quality of the pizza. This is a pretty decent slice of New York style pizza. Solid thin crust, crispy with an okay cheese and sauce. It’s just a good slice, nothing insane. But I enjoy it. 6.8 Frankie.

Alright Frankie...

First Chico review. Setting a baseline for others to come. Will update/adjust score if needed later. Mushroom pizza: Good flop, crisp crust, no grease drip. Would have liked the toppings to be spread more evenly. Solid 7.3 though.