Celestino's NY Pizza & Pasta

Fire🔥🔥

Solid cheese slice.

Just got back from NY and New Haven. Had Celestinos prior. Wondered how it slotted in to the mix. Frank Pepe’s in New Haven was far above any other I’ve ever had. But Celestinos goes head to head with John’s of Time Square. Misses some of the rise in the crust like L’Industrie and other heavy hitters in NY. But still great taste, always consistent. Good pie. Best in Sac. Better than Giovanni’s

Super floppy.. should have asked for well done. Good crust..not greasy

Great cheese, crust is a little tough. Nice staff will try again

This is not NY pizza. Thick crust and heavy cheese, sauce has no flavor.

Very evident that the crust is scratch made. Perfect cheese. Nice sauce. Fresh toppings. This place lives up to its good reputation.

Great pizza. Crust is good. Nice and thin. Just has a little too much cheese and too much grease to be in the 8’s. Other than that, the crust and sauce are great. Good crisp

Great crust and cheese . Sauce not the sweet type.8

One of my go to spots in the area, would really like to leave a higher score but in the spirit of integrity, here’s the review. Ordered a half pepperoni and bacon, half margherita pie. Way more cheese than usual, slightly overpowers the crust and other ingredients. Slightly undercooked, producing some serious flop and lack of crunch. No basil on the margherita and entirely way too many tomatoes. Still a great tasting pie, just super inconsistent from what I’ve had here in past experiences.

Not the best pizza and lots of crust for a NY style

Very good pizza for the Sac area. Definitely one of my favorites here. A little floppy and a little greasy. Crust is pretty good. Cheese slice is pretty solid. The Danny DeVito is good. Nice store. Get the Cannoli!!

On a good day it can be one of the best slices you’ve ever had. On a bad day, which is rare, it’s still a great slice. Also, I definitely prefer the re-heated slices.

Great slices of pizza. Quality ingredients, nice crisp, and great flavor. Was a big hit with the family!

Amazing!!!

Nice crisp, good chew and not greasy.

Word around the campfire is that this place knows how to make a great pie. Crust had a nice crisp, tad bit of flop but tasted fantastic. Sauce is 🔥🔥

Crispy undercarriage not a lot of flavor in the sauce needs something more. Crust is great. Get that sauce some zest or tang and closer to 8.5.

1/2 White, 1/2 Tom Jones pizza. Really good crust, a little thick for true NY style but fresh.