Cella Bagels & Grill

Cheese tasted old? Just a bad slice honestly, ingredients tasted not fresh to be polite… Shame… when this place first opened years ago I tried it and liked it.. Maybe I caught a bad pie.. I’ll never know 😂

This was a huge disappointment considering they had a +7 rating. The crust was somehow borderline raw on the bottom but crunchy on the ends, and way too thin. The sauce was unremarkable. It’s a bad slice for Long Island. The Sicilian slice was pretty good, but that might be because I ate it right after the regular slice. I’d have to try it again by itself.

Crust is amazing, cheese is plentiful and sauce is tangy and delicious. Totally destroyed expectations.

Good, solid football pizza

Decent pizza. I raised the score a bit because the place inside was nice. I would not get the buffalo chicken again but I'd give them another chance on a different pie.

Not bad had a bit of a flop and didn’t have the crisp the other reviews stated but had good flavor though. Solid pizza

Wasn’t too happy about this slop delivered. Looks like they dropped it & picked it right back up. Mush & onions on half wasn’t that tasty. Regular half not so bad. No flop. Not too oily and crust had good crips and flavor. Middle of the road. Better options around. 5.5 on regular slice. 3.3 on mush & onion

Chesse is good, kind of oily, not a bad slice

Good slice of pizza. No grease or flop. Crust was dull though.