Ceres

Pro tip, if you are going into NYC for the day, and were thinking you might want to try this place, go there FIRST, and put your order in, then walk around, explore and do your shopping. The wait on a random cloudy Wednesday was an hour and 45 minutes in the middle of the afternoon. Came from Jersey, couldn’t wait, and some beautiful generous people saw our disappointment and gave us a slice of their pie. It was definitely amazing, I get the hype. Super quality ingredients, amazing crisp, great char. But do yourself a favor, and be prepared to wait for your order.

I’ve gotten all the pies they offer here. But please do yourself a favor: Get. The. Mushroom. It’s the best pizza you will have, anywhere (and I’ve just about had em all). For reference, I’d rate the regular cheese an 8.5, Tomato an 8.3 and the Nduja an 8.9.

OK, if we’re doing a score off of crisp and an hour wait for a pie this place would be the busiest in Manhattan. Otherwise sauce and cheese are fairly basic but crust is outstanding.

First time in NYC only having one afternoon to see the city and got the opportunity to check this pizza out. You can only buy the whole pie and when we got to the counter there was a 2 hour wait for a cheese pie. The people of NYC are so kind and one person must’ve over heard us talking about not having time to wait and gave us the last 3 pieces of their tomato pie. The experience was incredible, people are great, and the pie is absolutely deserving of a 9+ rating.

This pizza is top notch. Crust was cooked to perfection and the sauce was flavorful. A MUST-HAVE if you’re in Little Italy

8.6 Excellent crisp and cheese flavor. Perhaps the best crisp outside of New Haven. My favorite in manhattan behind John’s. If you have time, do it.

Great dough. Amazing sauce. Good crispy crust. Slightly more cheese (maybe). Almost as good as it gets

Best pizza in NY? Certainly took long enough to make!!!

Best pizza i’ve ever had

Best ever

Sometimes can be overdone and dry. Dough and taste of sauce is best in class. Gotta move the crust down a bit but it’s also a 1 of 1 pizza. No one doing it this way.

Best I’ve ever had been back many times

We waited for one hr in line and then came back 2.5 hrs later. The hype is too much but it is very good pizza

Tomato pie was incredible. So much flavor. Amazing ingredients. No flop. Crisp.

I can’t imagine a pizza better than this.

Amazing pizza best in Manhattan. Highlight of this pie for me was the tomato sauce.

Lived up to the hype. First bite you may hear an angelic choir. No flop. Great sauce and crust.