New York style pie. A strong nose of cheese with notes of tomato. Not much flop. A little too light on the sauce and a little heavy on the cheese. Overall, a good pie.
Order now on Slice
Order Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
kevin.doherty53/27/22, 2:57 a.m.
Got the "Old World” style pizza, ordered well done. Significantly better than the regular cheese in my opinion. Great pie. Hidden gem.
maxwell.lani9/24/21, 8:18 p.m.
Not too cheesy, light airy crust. Tangy sauce. Not too much flop and not too greasy. Solid pizza.
koby.foster6/21/21, 11:25 p.m.
a little floppy, but great tasting undercarriage. a lot of cheese which is fantastic but not much sauce. the buffalo drizzle on top makes it worthwhile however. the chicken is cooked perfectly not too dry not too rubbery. overall, it’s a really good pie
morgan.rutherford5/13/21, 11:27 p.m.
Sauce is very good, crust too. Great pizza, best I’ve had in Columbus.
boostyss4/24/21, 8:46 p.m.
Best pizza in Columbus. Been here a couple of times and have gotten a couple of different specialty pizzas each time. Perfect crust, great sauce, and fresh toppings. Very good tiramisu and their Nutella Pie is awesome. Very friendly staff.
theodore10/4/20, 12:35 a.m.
AMAZING pie with a perfect crunch. Also the garlic knots are good too
nyapprovedpizza8/25/20, 10:48 p.m.
Ok Georgia you got me. You got me good. You proved me wrong. I don’t know how you did it, but you did it. You actually have a good pizzeria. It’s also not just good, it’s amazing. I am shook at what just happened. This place, there’s something about it. It’s as if I entered a wormhole into the suburbia of New York and exited out on the south side of the Mason Dixon. When I walked into this place, I had good New York Pizzeria vibes. The music was on point and the decor wasn’t too much. It was perfect. To start off with the pizza, the crust ratio at the end of the pie is perfect. The crust had a nice charred flavor to it and it wasn’t too doughy nor too crunchy. It was perfect and it had some residual flour on it too that I always love. My only complaint is that at times, it tasted slightly stale but very slightly. Still, they got some very good crust. The cheese to sauce ratio was perfect which is very hard to come by around here. The cheese had an extraordinary flavor and it didn’t create that soupy contraption that happens with the sauce. It was perfectly melted. The sauce was above average in my opinion and you could actually taste it. This place has exceeded my expectations and I applaud you for that. I can tell the owner knows what he is doing and thank you very much for making my day today. You should be known as the standard for other pizzerias down South and even some Pizzerias in New York should hear what you have to say. You are that good! Go eat some pizza.
atlantapizzaguy8/14/19, 12:29 a.m.
On a mission to find the best pizza in Georgia. This will be the baseline.
josh.geiger3/16/19, 6:40 p.m.
Past visit would have gotten a higher score. Good but not great some flop and was lite on the cheese.
kai.kallio2/19/19, 1:27 a.m.
Perfect score for floppiness. Excellent char on crust. Good amount of cheese but grease was crossing into excessive territory. Could have used more sauce but overall good pie. That’s a review!
austin.kernels12/6/18, 10:00 p.m.
Good pizza. Probably the best in Columbus. However I lived in Italy for 4 years and been up to New York and had better, but don’t let this confuse you. This is good pizza.
eric.watkins9/22/18, 10:23 p.m.
Alright Frankie, Cerrone’s lives up to the hype! Very light with fresh ingredients no problem putting away a few slices! Crust has a good crunch and not a lot of flop! Great pizza overall!
frankthatguyfrank8/23/18, 11:48 p.m.
Dave you hold down NY, I got Columbus Ga. Cerrone’s Pizzeria in Columbus GA.
324 views•6 likes