About Cicero's Pizza
1,137 Yelp Reviews
sovietaced11/26/23, 3:13 a.m.
Feels a bit like a food hall. Great place for groups and families and it’s quite loud inside. Order at the counter and pick up the food yourself. Complete curveball from what I was expecting. First impression is that this is more of a Mickey Mouse pizza. The taste and the ingredients resemble frozen pizza quality and the pizza looks much less sophisticated in person. Many reviews mention that this is bar pizza but the crust more closely resembles an oily fried tortilla or a really thin pita bread. The only part about that resembles bar pizza to me is the lack of crust on the edges. The best part about the pizza was the cheese. The sauce felt overly sweet when I got a taste of some and the crust is completely bizarre. I was extremely hungry so the pizza hit the spot but I will probably never come here again.
ronny.johnston10/1/22, 8:03 a.m.
If cracker crust is your go to, this is the spot. Super thin, super crispy. Sauce had great depth which has to be dynamite on their sausage and mushroom. Counter staff were very friendly.
jay_murs6/16/22, 6:14 a.m.
Sauce is bold and robust with a bit of tang and a hint of wine. Crust is thin, crispy; with a nice crunch up to the last bite; but still chewy on top. Hard to compare to another local good pizza spot such as Slice of New York on Steven's Creek, as this is a different type of slice. As a Personal preference; this is my "Go to" pizza place in Silicon Valley.
joseph.schleef10/1/21, 10:21 p.m.
My family and I have had this pizza for over 40 year. 3 generations. It was the best pizza when I was 6 as it is today at 36. Large extra cheese is my favorite but so is the pepperoni. Has to be the top 5 in the Bay Area of not the whole state of CA. Thank you ciceros family from the Scionti family!!
jp.bolen9/11/21, 8:34 p.m.
Best pizza I have had in California so far. Bar pie style, thin, crispy, no flop - amazing flavor. It’s now the go-to.
kp.p7/18/21, 2:27 a.m.
Wow just wow. What a great Pizza. This is one of the best Pizza I've eaten in Bay Area so far. The crust was perfect and by looks it wins hands down. It is a 9.1 Pizza! You're missing out if you haven't tried this one.
sammy7022/22/20, 10:45 p.m.
Great crunch on this pie and it’s nice a light which is nice. Definitely a good pie but just didn’t give me enough to go any higher than a 7.2. Was hoping this place would be a great one. Good but not great.
naresh.singh8/7/19, 3:20 a.m.
Asked for extra sauce and well-done. Enjoyed that modification however still wasn’t particularly crispy. The dough has an oil in it that just isn’t for me. Flavor is similar to a pizza pocket.
cupertinostevie5/1/19, 3:34 a.m.
Baker's pride is beyond awesome!! Great sauce and toppings, and a crust that's as crispy as it gets.
nattywb3/23/19, 2:49 a.m.
This is hands down the best pizza on the planet. Only reason not a 10.0 bc you never know if a better place is out there. Secret tip if you’re a sauce fiend - ask for extra sauce.
brooke.garcia12/3/18, 2:42 a.m.
Crispy, thin crust with lots of flavor. Kind of salty for my taste but it was still a great slice!!