Ciminelli's Pizza & Restaurant

Solid neighborhood slice. Sauce is a little sweet and the cheese has that classic pull to it. Undercarriage was crisp but the slice still had some flop to it. I wouldn’t drive far to get this but if I’m in Bethpage, I’d definitely stop again.

Tasted like just plain cheap ingredients. If they were going to give me a pizza I’d drive across town to Gino’s for a decent slice

Juuuuuust gets into the 7’s in my opinion. Does the job. Typical slice here, nothing special and nothing to complain about. Football pie. Unfortunately this joint is my girls kids favorite place at the moment. It changes by where they hang out in the neighborhood when they’re out riding there bikes. This is why I have to eat it all the time?? Do they know who I am?? Ay oh. 😂

7.1 - Based on taste 4.9 - Based on size Pizzas always too small. they use smaller pizza boxes to make their pies look bigger than they really are

Crispy I like more tang. The sauce needs something more

Pretty nice and decent. Learnd bout this place from some thot on Jerusalem

Under cooked and chewy. Not bad.