Ciro's Pizza

Quality pizza but missing flavor in the sauce

Delicious classic Long Island slice been in the same location for decades people have always enjoyed it

No flop, good sauce, standard NY pizza. Little too doughy I like a nice crisp but overall not bad

Cheese soup, with cheap cheese

Best slice in smithtown. I hit a few local places and this was the best of the group. Strong unique bite and sauce was delicious. Good crunch level.

Best spot in town, I like to order it well done and you get some crunch and less flop. Always fresh ingredients and tastes good

Yuk - based on the ratings maybe I went to the wrong restaurant? This thing was a sloppy mess but had good flavor. It had a ton of flop, which I grade hard on, and was greasy. I didn’t finish the piece of pepperoni. I’m from CT and not sure how NYers can consider this good.

I though this was exceptionally good. The cheese was perfect and the sauce was just the right flavor for me to enjoy.

Excellent crust, very light. Large slices. Sauce is very good. Worth the drive

One of the best slices around

Simply the greatest slice in all of Suffolk County Long Island. Perfect cheese mixture, sweet and perfect tomato sauce, coupled with a nice thin crust with a medium flop make this the dominant regular slice.

Top tier pizza : 9.1 - perfect crust and by perfect I mean light, buttery, with a crisp up top. Thinner slice which promotes some flop so the execution needs to be good considering it is sauced up cheesed up and comes with a nice grease. - highly recommend eating right away as it is the best it will be. Cheese blend is very good, 8.5, sauce very good. True tomato flavor. 8.5. Blends to around the 9.1 level.

Little flop, very little sauce but still a solid slice, thin slice but slightly doughy. Buff chicken is 8.5

Very interesting taste, no flop. Average crust. Love the unique taste. Yum.

Traditional, a slight tang to the sauce.

Barely any flop, solid taste, good crunch, some flour dust, the greasey after taste really kills Tunis from being over an 8

Overall very good. Just a little to greasy

Solid quality pie. No flop. Considering the alternatives in this general area I have to give it a bump because it’s worth traveling for in comparison to what’s around so for that reason I give an 8.1. If there were better pizzas in my general area it make this pizza not worth driving 15-20 minutes for which would make it a 7.9